Real In Business

  • Subscribe to our RSS feed.
  • Twitter
  • StumbleUpon
  • Reddit
  • Facebook
  • Digg

Tuesday, 12 March 2013

Print vs. Digital: The Great Mr. Magazine vs. BoSacks Tweet-Off

Posted on 20:35 by Unknown
Two of the U.S. magazine industry's leading pundits, Dr. Samir Husni and Robert Sacks, held an impromptu but insightful debate via Twitter tonight about the extent to which digital media will displace print media.

Husni, AKA "Mr. Magazine", director of the Magazine Innovation Center at the University of Mississippi, started the friendly argument with this comment about the hilarious French toilet paper ad that Adweek posted yesterday (shown below): This video reminds of a debate I had with my friend Mr. Magazine: some years back. Enjoy

Sacks, AKA BoSacks, took up the gauntlet: I'm glad you remember the good 'ol days. I agree paper has some important & vital uses. But digital reading will be predominate

Mr. Magazine: at least paper never leaves your side when you most needed, below and above 10,000 ft, with or without the cabin's door
open or not

BoSacks: Those minor restrictions will be a faint memory soon. Technology is transitional & as good as it is paper is merely a technology

Mr. Magazine: technology that everyone is trying to replicate.I love digital,I love the web, I love my iPads (yes, iPads), but they are not paper

BoSacks: It is true paper is unique. No matter how hard you press on paper it will not refresh nor update its old & ancient information

Mr. Magazine: Good writers create timely and timeless stuff that becomes an experience in no need to refresh or update? Think War & Peace?

Mr. Magazine: By the way, let the world know that is the first BoSacks/Mr.Magazine™ Twitter Debate. Join in fellow debaters.

BoSacks: Let us agree that War & Peace would be good on any substrate. I'm sure its the words & thinking that matter not the dead trees.

Mr. Magazine: Those trees are alive and happy every time a person holds the books and magazines between their hands and read their pages.

BoSacks: Agreed trees are good to carry thought. But so are other media. Print will not go away,it just won't be the way most people read

Mr. Magazine: Tell that to the WSJ, POLITICO, Hearst, Condé Nast, TIME, National Geo, Meredith and the 10,000 other magazines on the stands...

BoSacks: Print will soon be a luxury item for only those that can afford it.For print to survive it needs to be of excellent quality only 

BoSacks: That fate of the newsstand is happening before our eyes. A downward trend for a decade. There is a plateau but not there yet

BoSacks: All newsstand sales are down with limited exception. Niche or big guy, it is currently headed south. trends tell all

    Mr. Magazine: I heard the above more than few years, back."In the next 5 years.." famous Bob's quote. Print + Digital is the Future. Not one way.

    BoSacks: nowhere in this conversation did I say 5 years,The future is digital with print as a smaller medium it is now the most expensive 

    Mr. Magazine: Have you checked the prices of the magazines? Have you checked the state of the economy? We don't need magazines, we want them?

    Mr. Magazine: I was quoting previous conversations my friend... the one that Bo always used: In the next five years this or that will take place

    BoSacks: five years ago I was right as the current market conditions have proven. I will be right in the next five and ten years too.

    Mr. Magazine: did I hear plastic logic? where do I buy it today? the better than paper, paper?... Cheers and until Sept. All the best

    BoSacks: Cheers & good night to all. A delightful debate on twitter. I will now finish watching the Hobbit. An act no paper device can do

    Mr. Magazine: Good night. Heading to my bed with six magazines I bought from the newsstands - pure heavenly delight. Experience making @ its best

    Related articles:  
    • Printed Magazines or Digital Magazines: Do We Have To Choose?
    • App-oplexy: Magazines on the iPad  
    • What Angry Birds Can Teach Publishers About Print  
    • Facebook Is Doomed, BoSacks Says

    Email ThisBlogThis!Share to XShare to Facebook
    Posted in BoSacks, Samir Husni | No comments
    Newer Post Older Post Home

    0 comments:

    Post a Comment

    Subscribe to: Post Comments (Atom)

    Popular Posts

    • Confusion, Misinformation Could Hinder USPS's Early-Retirement Push
      Confusion reigns among the 115,000 postal workers who received notices in the past few days about a buyout offer. The confusion could limit ...
    • Are E-Book Sales Reaching a Plateau?
      When the U.S. magazine industry gets hot and bothered about the latest craze, you can usually bet that trend is about to run out of steam. E...
    • Abitibi's New Name: A Portent of Things To Come?
      After considering hundreds of possible monikers, newsprint giant AbitibiBowater has chosen the name of a ship that was trapped in the Canadi...
    • An Affair Between a Printing Lobbyist and Rep. Boehner? Six Reasons Not to Believe It
      The claim that a printing-industry lobbyist is having an affair with GOP Congressional leader John Boehner – and that the New York Times is...
    • The Recycled Debate: Can We 'Get Beyond the Stereotypical Industry-Environmental Relationship'?
      My recent article about discussions between National Geographic and an environmental group has stirred up a debate about recycled paper be...
    • Are Competitors Putting the Squeeze on New Page and White Birch?
      When it comes to setting prices, North American paper companies have exhibited some strange behavior lately that is helping customers but ma...
    • Donahoe, No Potter Clone, Quickly Making His Mark
      With a radical management reorganization , including the break-up of the Intelligent Mail group, new Postmaster General Pat Donahoe showed o...
    • Bad Customer Service Is Built into the Design of U.S. Post Offices, Report Says
      Have you ever stood in a long, slow-moving line at a post office and wondered why only one employee was helping customers? The problem is th...
    • Courier Express and Postal Observer Lives Again
      After announcing last week it would shut down and going offline for a few days, respected postal blog Courier Express and Postal Observer ...
    • Flats Litigation System: USPS and Vendor Battling It Out Over Huge FSS Machines
      A multimillion-dollar dispute between the U.S. Postal Service and the long-time vendor that built its troubled Flats Sequencing System has l...

    Categories

    • AbitibiBowater
    • African American postal workers
    • Amazon
    • American Bankers Association
    • American Postal Workers Union
    • Angry Birds
    • antidumping
    • Apple
    • APWU
    • Area Mail Processing studies
    • Audit Bureau of Circulation (ABC)
    • automation refugees
    • Baldwin Technology Company
    • Barnes and Noble
    • Better Homes and Gardens
    • Bisphenol-A (BPA)
    • Bite me
    • black liquor
    • book industry
    • bookazines
    • Borders
    • boreal forest
    • BoSacks
    • Boston Print Buyers
    • Buckeye Technologies
    • BusinessWeek
    • Candace the Caribou
    • Catalyst Paper
    • Cathie Black
    • Champion Paper
    • Chicago Sun-Times
    • Chicago Tribune
    • co-mailing
    • coated groundwood
    • coated paper
    • coldset printing
    • color printing
    • Conde Nast
    • Congress
    • Consumer Price Index
    • Consumer Reports
    • content marketing
    • Cosmopolitan
    • CPI
    • D. Eadward Tree
    • Da Vinci Code
    • Darrell Issa
    • Dead Tree Edition
    • Deputy Postmaster General Ron Stroman
    • Digital IQ
    • direct mail
    • Discover Financial Services
    • Domtar
    • dropshipping
    • E Ink
    • e-books
    • ecologomania
    • electric vehicles
    • Elle Decor
    • Entertainment Weekly
    • Facebook
    • FedEx
    • First Class postage
    • Flats Sequencing System
    • Folio:
    • Forbes
    • ForestEthics
    • forests
    • Forever Stamps
    • freesheet paper
    • George Will
    • Georgia Pacific
    • Glatfelter
    • Google
    • Gordon Pritchard
    • Green America
    • green printing
    • Greenpeace
    • greenwashing
    • Greeting Card Association
    • Guitar World
    • Hearst
    • heatset printing
    • Idealliance
    • in Touch Weekly
    • Indonesia
    • Inspector General
    • Intelligent Mail Barcode
    • International Paper
    • iPad
    • Joint Committee on Taxation
    • KapStone
    • Kentucky Fried Forest
    • Kimberly-Clark
    • Kindle
    • Koch Industries
    • L.L. Bean
    • Leo Raymond
    • letter carriers
    • Life magazine
    • logging
    • magazine industry
    • Magazine Publishers of America
    • mail transport equipment
    • Mailers Technical Advisory Committee (MTAC)
    • Margie Dana
    • MeadWestvaco
    • Men's Journal
    • Meredith
    • MPA
    • Muscle and Fitness
    • National Association of Letter Carriers
    • National Geographic
    • NewPage
    • newspaper printing
    • newspapers
    • newsstand
    • Newsweek
    • Nook
    • Northrop Grumman
    • Office of Personnel Management
    • OK magazine
    • Packaging Corporation of America
    • paper prices
    • part-timers
    • Patti LaBelle
    • People magazine
    • Periodicals
    • Periodicals postage
    • phased retirement
    • Pitney Bowes
    • Port Hawkesbury
    • post office consolidation
    • postage rates
    • postal clerks
    • postal lottery
    • postal pensions
    • postal rates
    • Postal Regulatory Commission
    • postal salaries
    • Postmaster General Jack Potter
    • Postmaster General Pat Donahoe
    • Print Buyers International
    • print media
    • print prices
    • printing employment
    • Printing Industries of America
    • printing prices
    • Printing's Best Blogs
    • Publishing Executive
    • QR codes
    • Quad/Graphics
    • QuadGraphics
    • Quebecor World
    • R.R. Donnelley
    • Readers Digest Association
    • recycled paper
    • Rep. Dennis Ross
    • Rep. Peter DeFazio
    • Resolute Forest Products
    • retiree health benefits
    • Reuters
    • Richard Nixon
    • RISI
    • Robert W. Mitchell
    • Rock-Tenn
    • Rodale
    • Rolling Stone
    • Rosie magazine
    • Ruth Goldway
    • Samir Husni
    • Sammy Smartphone
    • San Francisco Chronicle
    • SAPPI
    • Saturday delivery
    • search engine optimization
    • Second Ounce Free
    • Sen. Max Baucus
    • Sen. Thomas Carper
    • Sonoco Products
    • Standard postage
    • Star magazine
    • Stern Partners
    • StoraEnso
    • subscriptions
    • supercalendered paper
    • sustainable forestry
    • tablets
    • Temple-Inland
    • The Atlantic Monthly
    • The Wall Street Journal
    • Thurgood Marshall Jr.
    • timber industry
    • Time Inc.
    • Time magazine
    • Toshiba
    • Traditional Home
    • Transcontinental Inc.
    • Twitter
    • Two Sides
    • U.S. News and World Report
    • U.S. Postal Service
    • United Parcel Service
    • UPM
    • USPS bankruptcy
    • USPS employment levels
    • USPS network optimization
    • USPS privatization
    • VERA
    • Verle Sutton
    • Verso
    • Veterans Job Corps
    • Viagra
    • Voluntary Early Retirement (VERA)
    • Washington Post
    • West Linn
    • West Virginia
    • Weyerhaeuser
    • White Birch Paper
    • William Burrus
    • Worldcolor

    Blog Archive

    • ►  2014 (2)
      • ►  January (2)
    • ▼  2013 (57)
      • ►  December (4)
      • ►  November (4)
      • ►  October (8)
      • ►  September (7)
      • ►  August (3)
      • ►  July (4)
      • ►  June (3)
      • ►  May (4)
      • ►  April (4)
      • ▼  March (4)
        • Using Recycled Paper in Magazines Protects the Env...
        • What Magazine Publishers Can Learn From "The Da Vi...
        • Print vs. Digital: The Great Mr. Magazine vs. BoSa...
        • Postal Workforce Is Both Shrinking and Growing
      • ►  February (6)
      • ►  January (6)
    • ►  2012 (90)
      • ►  December (4)
      • ►  November (8)
      • ►  October (7)
      • ►  September (11)
      • ►  August (6)
      • ►  July (7)
      • ►  June (7)
      • ►  May (6)
      • ►  April (8)
      • ►  March (8)
      • ►  February (6)
      • ►  January (12)
    • ►  2011 (111)
      • ►  December (5)
      • ►  November (8)
      • ►  October (13)
      • ►  September (9)
      • ►  August (9)
      • ►  July (8)
      • ►  June (12)
      • ►  May (6)
      • ►  April (9)
      • ►  March (10)
      • ►  February (11)
      • ►  January (11)
    • ►  2010 (40)
      • ►  December (6)
      • ►  November (14)
      • ►  October (14)
      • ►  September (6)
    Powered by Blogger.

    About Me

    Unknown
    View my complete profile